Blog/Latest News - 20th August 2011 - 2 Comments »
Lawyer to 3 Americans: Eight-Year Prison Sentence Disproportionate With Charges

Massoud Shafiee told the Campaign that he will submit an appeal bill to the court during the allotted 20 days after the ruling is served to him. According to what IRNN has announced, Branch 15 of the Tehran Revolutionary Court has sentenced Josh Fattal and Shane Bauer to three years in prison for illegal entry and five years in prison on espionage charges. It was said that Sarah Shourd's case remains open.
Massoud Shafiee, the lawyer representing the three Americans on trial in Iran, told the International Campaign for Human Rights in Iran that he was uninformed of the ruling issued by the lower court in his clients’ cases, as announced on Iranian television today. According to what Iranian media announced today, Josh Fattal and Shane Bauer were each sentenced to three years in prison for illegal entry and to another five years on charges of espionage. Shafiee told the Campaign that just as soon as the ruling is officially served to him, he will express his opinion about it. Asked whether it is possible to file suit against the judge with the Judges Court for issuing a sentence that is not supported by the evidence in the case, he told the Campaign: “The Judge, unfortunately, is not committed to the requirement of ‘proportionate sentencing;’ we have ways of recourse available to us.”
Iranian state television’s News Network (IRNN) merely stated its news source as “a judicial authority,” without mentioning his name. “Allegations of espionage were reflected both in the indictment and in the statements made by the Prosecutor’s Representative, but as far as presenting reasons in this area, I’d have to say there were absolutely no reasons,” Shafiee told the Campaign. Shafiee also expressed dismay about the Iranian Judiciary’s announcement of the ruling on television prior to informing him. “And this shows how lawyers are regarded in this country. Instead of serving the ruling to the lawyer according to law, they announce it elsewhere,” he said. Shafiee said he will go to courthouse tomorrow to find out the details of the lower court’s ruling.
Massoud Shafiee told the Campaign that he will submit an appeal bill to the court during the allotted 20 days after the ruling is served to him. According to what IRNN has announced, Branch 15 of the Tehran Revolutionary Court has sentenced Josh Fattal and Shane Bauer to three years in prison for illegal entry and five years in prison on espionage charges. It was said that Sarah Shourd’s case remains open.
Asked whether the evidence presented in court was proportionate with the announced sentence of his clients, Shafiee told the Campaign: “It is not proportionate at all. I did not expect such a ruling at all. I told Shane and Josh, too…unfortunately, under the current circumstances I have no contact with them, either. Even so, there are still ways to defend them.”
2 Comments
Connie
Debbie Nestor
What are people thinking is the reason the Iran court is taking this stance? Is it possible they really believe these young explorers were really caring about what the Iran government is doing? It doesn’t make sense, what possible information were they going to be able to get at some remote mountain top? The charges have no reason.
Make a Comment
Recently Added Content
- Speak Out for Imprisoned Students
- Student Group Report Calls for End to "Educational Apartheid"
- After 19 Months in Solitary, Death Row Inmate Finally Indicted
- Supreme Court Unlawfully Confirms Kurdish Prisoner’s Execution
- Weekly Cartoon: The Cartoonist's Sorrow
- Imprisoned Kurdish Citizen Transferred for Unknown Reason
- Imprisoned Student Beaten in Front of Parents
- Prominent Lawyer Mohammad Ali Dadkhah Sentenced To Nine Years
- CIVICUS: Iran must revoke harsh sentences against human rights defenders
- UN STATEMENT: Independent UN Experts Urge Iran to Ensure Protection for Rights Defenders
- “Confess on TV or Go to Prison,” Authorities Tell Dadkhah
- Student Group Report Calls for End to “Educational Apartheid”
- 4 Comments » - Iranian physicist sentenced to prison: Nature news and comment
- Weekly Cartoon: The Cartoonist’s Sorrow
- 2 Comments » - Malekpour Family Allowed Visit After Three Months
- Iran Tries to Neuter Foreign Media and International Press Freedoms
- “Confess on TV or Go to Prison,” Authorities Tell Dadkhah
- 1 Comment » - Detention Extended for Gonabadi Dervish Just Before Release
- UN STATEMENT: Independent UN Experts Urge Iran to Ensure Protection for Rights Defenders
- 1 Comment » - Weekly Cartoon (4): Iran’s Border Burdens
- CIVICUS: Iran must revoke harsh sentences against human rights defenders
- 1 Comment » - Protestant Pastor Sentenced to Six Years
- Let's not forget that Iran bans any education in mother tongue fro Azeris, Arabs...
- UN and other organizations should help this starres students to go back to their...
- a perfect report...
- it has nothing to do with Ahmadinejad. his ministers are under the orders of som...
- با سلام لطفاّ درمورد نقض حقوق بشر نژاد پرستی دولت مردان ایران و اینکه حقوق دی...
- I'm a Christian and I believe Dadkhah is a very brave Attorney. I respect him st...
- salam mani aziz mesle hamishe ziba tasir gozar...
- Strong and true!...
Women’s Rights
The Iranian women’s rights movement is the most vibrant social movement in Iran today. Having built an extensive grassroots base, Iranian women are campaigning to fight legal gender discrimination. The government routinely persecutes and prosecutes women’s rights activists.
Report on the Status of Women Human Rights Defenders — April 2009
The Systematic Repression of Women — May 2008
_____________________________________
More on Women’s Rights
- Sotoudeh’s Husband Says Wife is in Solitary Confinement
- 6 Comments » - Fruitless Efforts to Reduce Shahidi’s $600,000 Bail
- 1 Comment » - “I Think They Have Demands Of Her Which She Does Not Wish To Grant,” Says Sotoudeh’s Husband
- 3 Comments » - Mourning Mothers Request Nasrin Sotoudeh’s Release to Attend Father’s Funeral
Academic Freedom
During the past few years, Iranian universities have been experiencing a new phase of government intervention in academic affairs, which is considered a second Cultural Revolution. The present government policy is demonstrated on several fronts and is resulting in severe infringements on academic freedoms.
Report on the Situation of Academic Freedom on University Campuses — December 2008
_____________________________________
More on Academic Freedom
- Government Attacks Baha’i Online University, Detains 30 Instructors
- 6 Comments » - Another New Year Spent in Exile Prison for Ailing Student
- Faculty Member Dismissed for Publishing Articles
- Imprisoned Female Student Activists Denied Visitation Rights Again
- 1 Comment »
Workers’ Rights
Iranian workers and teachers are denied many protections of basic workers rights, as defined and articulated under longstanding international labor standards. Iranian workers are deprived of such fundamental rights both under Iranian labor law and in practice.
Background Information on the Rights of Workers in Iran — March 2008
_____________________________________
More on Workers’ Rights
- Labor Leader’s Sister Asks for His Release to Treat Three Blocked Arteries
- Taxi Drivers Strike to Protest Low Fares in Babol
- Unionist Reza Shahabi on Wet Hunger Strike
- 2 Comments » - Trade Unionist on Dry Hunger Strike, Grave Concerns for his Health
- 2 Comments » - Clampdown on Teachers and Labor Activists
- 1 Comment »




This is a tragedy, send these innocent boys home. This country is just simply unbelievable barbaric the way you treat human beings. They seem to have no meaning to you especially women. I wish all that could would just simply leave that country, Don’t stay there if you can get away.